Measurements from actinic flux spectroradiometers on board the NASA DC-8 during the Atmospheric Tomography (ATom) mission provide an extensive set of statistics on how clouds alter photolysis rates (J-values) throughout the remote Pacific and Atlantic Ocean basins. ATom made profiling circumnavigations of the troposphere over four seasons during 2016–2018. J-values are a primary chemical control over tropospheric ozone and methane abundances and their greenhouse effects. Clouds have been recognized for more than three decades as being an important factor in tropospheric chemistry. The ATom climatology of J-values is a unique test of how the chemistry models treat clouds. This work focuses on measurements over the Pacific during the first deployment (ATom-1) in August 2016. Nine global chemistry–climate or –transport models provide J-values for the domains measured in ATom-1. We compare mean profiles over a range of cloudy and clear conditions; but, more importantly, we build a statistical picture of the impact of clouds on J-values through the distribution of the ratio of J-cloudy to J-clear. In detail, the models show largely disparate patterns. When compared with measurements, there is some limited, broad agreement. Models here have resolutions of 50–200 km and thus reduce the occurrence of clear sky when averaging over grid cells. In situ measurements also average the scattered sunlight, but only out to scales of 10 s of km. A primary uncertainty remains in the role of clouds in chemistry, in particular, how models average over cloud fields, and how such averages can simulate measurements.